In his "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction," Walter Benjamin lamented loss of art's appeal due to infinite reproducibility of photography. The time was early 20th century and the promise of mechanization enticed and mesmerized humanity. It only made sense that its enormous potential was, for some, the jeopardy for originality. In its place, we got entertainment industry, consumerism, kitsch and mass culture.
Rewind to Canada, circa 2013, and ask what happens when an ad agency gets its hands on a 3D printer? As the unavidable British accent (this is advertising, after all) in the promotional video states, "3D printer allows us to bring any object to life with a click of a mouse."
Indeed. Yet, faced with abundance of human life-improving options, what does an ad agency do with its treasured, rather pricey, possession? It starts printing advertising awards. To be more precise, 800 gold Cannes Lions and 194 One Show's Silver Pencils.
Why?
The official story is that this is a stunt to promote a local ad show. The unofficial story can be easily interpreted either as a serious case of award envy or yet another proof of ad industry's egocentrism. Or, most likely, both.
But I am not interested in the whereabouts of Canadian ad agencies. I wonder what happens with the award-winning work in the age of 3-D reproduction, to paraphrase Benjamin.
Cannes Lions are not exactly objects of art, although some would definitely deem the rewarded work as such. Reproduction of a symbolic object takes away that privilege.
But it's not about the awards, even if their commoditization ruffles our feathers. Truth to be told, ad award have already lost so much of its allure so it's not like reproducing them can be deemed responsible for that.
It's about the values, and this little Canadian agency inadvertedly throws it into our faces. 3-D printing is the doman of The Maker: a domain of solving problems like word hunger, infant mortality in the third world, and sustainable energy. It's created by The Maker, for The Makers. With each printed objects, this technology spreads values of humanity, collaboration, democracy and progress.
Advertising awards are reflection of the values of entertainment, consumerism, kitsch and mass culture. To 3-D print a Cannes Lion, and a gold one in that, is to crush these values. That's why it's so bothersome to the industry.
Our optimism about 3-D printing is the same the optimism that spread through the early 20th century with mechanization. It's only natural that someone's going to show up and point out how it eats away at our values. In this case, it's a good thing.
Recent Comments